Located at 6461 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043, United States, Italian Prime At Salvatore's stands as a distinguished destination for those seeking an elevated dining experience. This establishment blends the timeless traditions of Italian culinary artistry with a sophisticated atmosphere, making it a cornerstone for local residents and visitors alike. Whether you are planning an intimate dinner, a celebratory gathering, or a professional meeting, the restaurant offers a refined environment designed to cater to a variety of occasions. The commitment to quality and hospitality is evident from the moment you step through the doors, reflecting a deep respect for the heritage of Italian cuisine while embracing a modern approach to fine dining.
The philosophy behind Italian Prime At Salvatore's is rooted in the belief that a memorable meal is about more than just the food on the plate; it is about the entire sensory experience. The interior design strikes a balance between elegance and comfort, providing a backdrop that encourages conversation and relaxation. By focusing on the integrity of ingredients and the precision of preparation, the kitchen team strives to deliver dishes that resonate with authenticity and flavor. Every aspect of the service is curated to ensure that guests feel welcomed and well-attended to throughout their visit, reinforcing the restaurant's reputation as a premier choice in the Depew area.
Key Highlights of the Dining Experience
Commitment to Culinary Excellence: The kitchen prioritizes the use of high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every dish reflects a dedication to authentic Italian flavors and techniques. From classic preparations to contemporary interpretations, the menu is crafted to satisfy diverse palates.
Sophisticated Atmosphere: The restaurant features a carefully designed interior that creates an inviting yet upscale ambiance. It is an ideal setting for those looking to enjoy a quiet evening or host a special event in a space that feels both exclusive and comfortable.
Attentive Professional Service: A hallmark of the dining experience at this location is the high standard of hospitality. The staff is trained to provide knowledgeable and seamless service, ensuring that every guest's needs are met with professionalism and care.
Strategic Location in Depew: Situated conveniently on Transit Road, the restaurant is easily accessible for those traveling within the region. Its central position makes it a natural choice for both local patrons and those exploring the culinary landscape of New York.
Beyond the individual elements of food and service, Italian Prime At Salvatore's fosters a sense of community. It serves as a gathering place where the simple joy of sharing a meal is elevated to an art form. The attention to detail—from the arrangement of the dining room to the pacing of the meal—demonstrates a clear understanding of what makes a restaurant truly stand out. Guests are invited to explore a menu that honors the rich history of Italian cooking while enjoying the comfort of a modern, well-appointed venue.
As you plan your next outing in Depew, consider the unique blend of tradition and elegance offered at this establishment. The team at Italian Prime At Salvatore's remains dedicated to maintaining the high standards that have made it a notable part of the local dining scene. Whether you are a long-time fan of Italian cuisine or simply looking for a high-quality meal in a welcoming environment, this restaurant provides a consistent and enjoyable experience that invites you to return time and again. We look forward to welcoming you to our table and sharing our passion for exceptional food and hospitality.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Menus
Photos
Reviews Italian Prime At Salvatore's
Waldo Valdivia
19-06-2026
I had the pleasure of dining at an Italian restaurant During my recent trip to Buffalo that truly exceeded all expectations. The food was absolutely amazing—every dish was bursting with flavor, from the perfectly cooked pasta to the rich, … More
Shanay Gaines
01-06-2026
Exceptional experience from start to finish. The atmosphere and overall vibe was absolutely perfect — elegant, beautiful, and comfortable all at once. The temperature, lighting, and setting were done perfectly and really created a true fine dining experience.
Our waiter was fantastic, very knowledgeable about the dishes, attentive, and consistently checked in on us throughout the night to make sure everything was going well. The busser also did an amazing job keeping the table clear, moving things out of the way, and making sure our waters stayed filled without us ever having to ask. The service overall was truly on point the entire evening.
The food was 10/10 and you can absolutely taste the quality in every dish. This is high quality fine dining and completely worth the experience. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!
Price per person
USD 100+
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reservation
Reservations recommended
Noise level
Moderate noise
Wait time
No wait
Reagan Wright
20-05-2026
We had the most incredible experience at Italian Prime at Salvatore’s for my cousin’s graduation dinner. Our servers, Giovanni and Jeff (apologies if the spelling is off!), were absolutely phenomenal. They went above and beyond to … More
Matthew Hoeltje
25-04-2026
We had our Christmas dinner here tonight and the decorations were amazing and the kids loved seeing Santa. But the food was not so great. My steak and potatoes were dry. The salad and Lobster Bisque soup was good. Waitress tonight was a … More
Dartania Rehn Sho
02-04-2026
The food is very good and the only reason it didn't get 5 stars is because I swear I tasted traditional Caesar dressing with anchovy on the salad even though they claimed it was ranch. Someone else at our table noticed and stated the same … More
David Weiss
14-03-2026
Birthday dinner for 10. Enjoyed the overdone holiday decor. Seated promptly at reservation time and received impeccable service throughout. All food was quite good, but nothing especially unique or ground breaking. Several folks had the prime rib, which was really excellent. Special occasion prices
. More
T Tat
13-03-2026
The restaurant is beautiful because it is located inside a hotel and reservations can be made in Resy. However I do not recommend this place.
1. We arrived at 7:11pm for our 7:15pm reservation and was seated after 5 minutes of arrival. We then ordered our food after 20 minutes. At the point we would just be waiting. To our long wait, the food didn’t come out until after 9PM. So we waited over 1.5 hrs for the food.
2. Food was average for how expensive everything was. My risotto was salty, even the tomatoes were salty.
I will not come back.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 5
Albert Hayden
12-03-2026
Excellent atmosphere. Wonderful time at New Years party. Nice music. Tasty food. Wonderful drinks. Amazing time. The place was packed with nice positive mature people. I definitely plan to go again. The costumes added a nice touch to a wonderful time. More
Ronald McKenica
07-02-2026
I was shocked at how bad the food was! I usually go to Russells, but was invited to a birthday party here. I had not been in Salvatore's for many years, but figured it wouldn't have changed that much. Well, IT DID! The service was just ok … More
andrew woiccak
26-01-2026
Great experience at Salvatore’s Italian Prime Rib. I ordered the filet medium rare and really enjoyed it, and my girlfriend’s strip steak was very good as well.
My buddy ordered his steak medium (questionable choice to begin with 😂), and it came out closer to well done. The staff handled it quickly and professionally, were very apologetic, and made it right with no hassle.
The highlight of the night was definitely the service — big shoutout to Jeff for being attentive, friendly, and making the whole experience even better. We’ll definitely be back.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Jordan Collins
14-01-2026
We went for a birthday dinner and Mike was our waiter. My kid's haven't been taken to a "fancy" restaurant in many years. Mike was able to put them at ease with the menu and accommodate their requests and questions. I ordered the "Apple a … More
Hannah
27-11-2025
This establishment is top notch!! Everything from the decor, gift shop, the Buffalo Bills game playing on the TV in the bar for guests to watch, festive decorations in every part of the restaurant, friendly staff and delicious food. My experience was amazing! More
Steve Valeri
09-11-2025
My wife and I went to celebrate her birthday. After ordering drinks, we were told the $50 off for a birthday does not apply on Saturdays! Guessing that's the day most people go there! The waiter said the boss won't budge on that … More
Solmarie Garcia
19-09-2025
I wish I can give 0 stars review! I do not recommend eating at Italian Prime. This by far is the worst experience I've had at a so called "fine restaurant ". Food is way to pricey and not even that tasty or good.
I made a reservation 3 weeks ago to celebrate Valentines day with my partner. We arrived 8 minutes before our reservation for 7:45pm. We waited over an hour to get just an appetizer that was not really that great. One of the forks in the table was very dirty, still had left over food stick to it. When they brought my Vermont Salad, it was dry, it barely had any dressing and it included a PLASTIC PIECE 🤮. I return it and received a new plate. At this point I am getting irritated, mind you it's already 9:30 pm and the Entree haven't arrived. When the food finally arrives 2 hours later, the steak I ordered was suppose to be medium well. I received a bloody rare steak. Of course I return it, but at this point I am very frustrated, hungry and mad. The server return it to the kitchen and brings back a well done steak inside a to go bowl. Something I definitely did not ask for.
I was supposed to have a great experience and I definitely did not have it. And that is my fault, for having high expectations for a place that has so many bad reviews.
And I also overheard a couple next to us that they didn't like their food either. They didn't even eat it.
Price per person
USD 100+
Food: 1
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3
Noise level
Loud, but you can still talk
Special events
Seasonal / holiday event
Dave Doherty
16-09-2025
The place decorated for Christmas looked great, however the service was really slow. The food was just okay...
Also, two of us ordered Glenlivet scotch which was on the menu for $12 and we … More
Valerie Muscoreil
01-09-2025
This was our second visit to this establishment. We were very happy with our experience. GEO was our server and let me tell you he was awesome. Seriously a server can make or break your experience. He was outstanding. His recommendations were spot on. We enjoyed everything. Food was great, came out hot. We ordered dessert and it was delicious. The place is beautiful and very clean. Prices are okay considering the quality, service, setting and portions.
We had steak,seafood and pasta everything was perfect. The spinach bread was hands down fantastic and could be a meal in itself! Double thumbs up even though tragically the Buffalo Bills lost to Denver this night😮💨 We will be back
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Wait time
No wait
Recommendation for vegetarians
Not sure
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Palma G
15-08-2025
Love coming here food is amazing and the ppl working here are so friendly and very entertaining I have been here 3 times and its always the same amazing food every time More
Ashley Gostomski
26-07-2025
I want to start by saying the appetizers were good. We had the coconut shrimp and salad. I had the filet mignon from the specials menu. It was prepared properly and flavorful. However, my date had the 12 oz strip steak and it was extremely … More
CHV
11-05-2025
Salvatore’s is an experience! From their extensive collections displayed around the establishment to the tuxedo clad servers, it’s determined to impress their guests. They decorate for each season, and they have a lovely gift shop offering … More
Zohreh Mohajeri
05-05-2025
My husband and I had an excellent night at Salvatore's for our anniversary. It was the kind of service we expected to have. The owner of the restaurant was present and was welcoming everyone entering which gave a personal touch to the … More
Reviews Italian Prime At Salvatore's